Rebecca Reads

Classics, Nonfiction, and Children's Literature

  • About
  • Blog
    • Non-Reviews
    • Reviews
      • Child/Young Adult
        • Board Books
        • Chapter Books
        • Early Chapter Books
        • Middle Grade
        • Picture Books
        • Young Adult
      • Fiction
        • Drama
        • Short Stories
        • Poetry
      • Nonfiction
  • Reading Lists
  • Contact
  • Line upon Line Learning
You are here: Home / Reviews / Nonfiction / Biography/Memoir / Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony: A Friendship that Changed the World by Penny Colman

Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony: A Friendship that Changed the World by Penny Colman

October 13, 2011 by Rebecca Reid

I wonder if my recent news about my upcoming arrival prompted me to notice this book on the New Books shelf? Possibly. Baby Monkey is a GIRL! and I’m delighted and excited that Raisin will have a little sister.

At any rate, when I saw the biography of the two foremost proponents of women’s rights (at least for the last half of the 1800s), I felt the need to pick it up and read it. For, although I know the name of Elizabeth Cady Stanton and I’ve of course been exposed the Susan B. Anthony as an historical figure, I knew very little of the work, the lives, and the legacy of the two women.

Penny Colman’s young adult biography of the two women (titled Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony: A Friendship That Changed the World) tells their story, especially focusing on the women’s rights work that they dedicated their lives to. Although the book had some flaws, it was full of history that I needed to learn and I’m glad I read it.

Penny Colman begins by describing the childhoods of the two women in alternating chapters. I was struck as I considered how young Elizabeth must have felt, for example, when her father praised her intelligence only to sigh, “Ah! You should have been a boy!” It showed me that our opinions and comments that young children hear do make an impression on the child. She never seemed to forget that her father, while he loved her and encouraged her in many ways, still felt her potential was lost since she was a girl.

Elizabeth’s subsequent life seemed to prove him wrong. She married and raised seven children, and she also managed to work in the public sphere as a speaker and social activist, fighting for the rights of women in her society. On the other hand, Susan’s Quaker upbringing did not discourage her from gaining a strong education as good as that of her brothers, but she did likewise become involved in the social issues of the day, from abolition of slavery to temperance, her preferred topic. When Susan and Elizabeth met in 1851, they found in each other a potential ally for changing some of the social problems of the day.

Penny Colman’s biography was strongest in part 1, when it focused on the girl’s upbringings. She seemed to have a tone of personality that brought me, as a reader, in to the lives of the two girls. As the two aged, Ms Colman’s text seemed to get more bogged down with details. I wasn’t as interested in all of the conventions. Granted, the two women spent lots of time in the political sphere, and these needed to be mentioned. However, the personalities of the two women seemed to sink below the political details. It was not as engaging reading to me as the women aged, and I wonder how young adults would feel as they read the story. Would they make it to the end of the women’s lives given the extensive political dates and details?

Because I began to feel a lack of connection with the women as the years passed, I also felt there were many details that were left unsaid. I didn’t remember Elizabeth’s husband and was surprised to find that he died in her relatively old age: for more than 100 pages, I didn’t recall hearing about him at all. Certainly, Elizabeth’s work was for women and he didn’t seem too eager to support her in the beginning. But how did their subsequent marriage work? It seemed to me that important personal matters would have added personality to the impressive lives I read about. I got a good feel for their personalities, but something seemed to be missing.

I needed to read about these impressive women and the work they accomplished. It was shocking to hear about the abuse that women had to endure simply because they were women. Some of the women’s experiences sounded like the women were trapped in slavery, and while abolition of slavery was eventually abolished by the Civil War, it took Elizabeth and Susan more than 50 years of their life to reverse many of the discriminatory laws which entrapped women in abuse marriages. Even then, the vote wasn’t granted to women until 1920, 14 years after Susan’s death. This is shocking, considering that Elizabeth’s first women’s rights convention occurred in 1848. As a woman, soon to bring another future woman in to the world, I found it important to learn just what a struggle was wagged for women’s rights.

In short, then, Penny Colman’s tribute to the two feminists greatly encouraged me, but the book didn’t give the two women personality details that would have made them come alive. I am glad I read it, though, because I know I was rather ignorant of the history these two women worked for.

Related posts:

  1. Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World that Can’t Stop Talking by Susan Cain
  2. Listen to the Wind by Greg Mortenson and Susan L. Roth
  3. The Awakening by Kate Chopin
  4. Why Women Should Rule the World by Dee Dee Myers

Filed Under: Biography/Memoir, Child/Young Adult, Nonfiction, Reviews, Young Adult Tagged With: feminism, history, marriage, slavery, social issues, women, women's constraints, women's issues, women's roles

← The Woman in White by Wilkie Collins (Brief Thoughts on a Reread) (Kids Corner) Some Cybils 2011 Books about … Babies and Birthdays →


Comments

  1. Christina says

    October 13, 2011 at 7:46 am

    Congratulations on the baby being a girl! How very exciting!

    • Rebecca Reid says

      October 14, 2011 at 3:40 pm

      Christina » we’re excited!

  2. Julie @ Read Handed says

    October 13, 2011 at 9:44 am

    This sounds like such a good book! I’ve learned peripherally about these two women, but never in depth. This book seems like a good place to start. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and congratulations on your baby girl!

    • Rebecca Reid says

      October 14, 2011 at 3:41 pm

      Julie @ Read Handed » I think it is a good place to start — because it doesn’t give too much info. I guess my only qualms were for the age group it was geared towards. Would TEENS stick with all the facts in the latter chapters?

  3. Jillian says

    October 13, 2011 at 5:22 pm

    I definitely want to read something on these two women, whether it’s this book or another. I think Ken Burns made a documentary out of their story. I haven’t seen it yet, but he’s my favorite for historical documentaries…

    • Rebecca Reid says

      October 14, 2011 at 3:42 pm

      Jillian » I don’t watch many documentaries, but that would be interesting too. Definitely a good friendship to read about, and the bonus is that this is rather short, since it’s geared for teens.

  4. Tony Scott says

    October 14, 2011 at 4:08 am

    Ah, another piece of literature that I must have! Stories of courage exhibited by women cannot be ignored! More reading time coming soon. Thanks for the preview and info.

    • Rebecca Reid says

      October 14, 2011 at 3:43 pm

      Tony Scott » This is nonfiction, not literature, but it certainly is a great historical friendship to be discovered.

  5. Kailana says

    October 15, 2011 at 5:19 am

    This might be a subject that would have been better if it was an adult book…. It would have maybe covered them in more detail.

    Congrats on having a girl!

    • Rebecca Reid says

      October 20, 2011 at 7:57 am

      Kailana » I think it had plenty of detail but little of the other stuff that gave them personality. So I’m not sure that’s it. A good historical story to know about, for sure.

Rebecca Reads Classics, Nonfiction, and Children's Literature

Reflections on great books from an avid reader, now a homeschooling mom

Search for a Book Review

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Archives

open all | close all

Authors, Publishers, and Publicists

Please refer to my review policy before sending me a request to read your book for review.

Disclosure

Occasionally, I accept copies of books for review consideration. All such books will be tagged "Review Copy". Accepting a book for review does not affect my opinion of the book.

I am also an Amazon affiliate. Items purchased via Amazon through a link on any of these pages may result in a commission to me. Thank you for your support.
All content © Rebecca Reads 2008-2015 All Rights Reserved.
Protected by Copyscape Plagiarism Detector

About This Blog
Privacy and Disclosure Policy (on Line upon Line Learning blog)
Book Review Policy
Contact Rebecca Reid

Advertisement



Browse My Educational Products Shop!

Copyright © 2021 · Beautiful Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in