14 Responses

  1. Tuesday
    Tuesday February 16, 2009 at 10:58 pm | | Reply

    Sounds like everything’s been a bit hectic over there; hope you’re settling in okay :D

    Personally, I’m not all that comfortable with audiobooks because it feels strange to listen to a book, particularly if I don’t like the narrator’s voice.
    Only exception is the Harry Potter audiobooks. Stephen Fry does the best job ever. It’s almost better than reading the books, hahah!

  2. Kathy
    Kathy February 17, 2009 at 7:47 am | | Reply

    I’m glad your move went so well. We’ve moved a lot so I know how much work it is. The last audio book I listened to was Little Pink House and I loved it.

  3. Rebecca Reid
    Rebecca Reid February 17, 2009 at 7:48 am | | Reply

    Tuesday, I’ve found that I often don’t mind odd narration: I even listen to computer-generated voices or Librivox (which is amateur narration) sometimes because that means I can listen to the books I want to get to. But I think audiobooks are an acquired taste. I’d just rather “read” a book by audio rather than watch tv or listen to music. So when I’m doing tedious things it’s worth going to an audiobook.

    I’d still much rather sit down and read a book!

  4. Steph
    Steph February 17, 2009 at 8:53 am | | Reply

    I’ve long known that I’m someone who is very visual, so I find it a bit hard to get into an audiobook. I’ll find my attention wandering, and they’re definitely not my preferred means of connecting with a book. I did try listening to audiobooks on the treadmill, as I have had no luck actually reading while running, but I’ve definitely found that the best books for that are pretty simple ones such as the Twilight series (where the narration is so repetitive that it really doesn’t matter if I zone out for a bit!). I don’t want anything with complicated prose, because I need to be able to see that and have the chance to go back over dense passages. Like Tuesday, I’ve also enjoyed the Harry Potter audiobooks, as I know the stories so well and Jim Dale (for the North American versions) really goes all out. I think I’d probably enjoy listening to murder mysteries by Agatha Christie on tape too! They seem like they’d lend themselves well to the audio form.

    Also, I think Animal Farm, and P&P were probably great audiobook choices! I think I wouldn’t mind listening to those either, but again, I’ve had the firsthand visual experience with them first.

  5. Kim (Sophisticated Dorkiness)
    Kim (Sophisticated Dorkiness) February 17, 2009 at 9:34 am | | Reply

    The first audio book I listened to was Twilight by Stephanie Meyer, which I liked a lot as an audiobook because it was easy to listen to. I tried Sideways by Rex Pickett, but that one didn’t hold me as much. I also tried Reading Like A Writer by Francine Prose (I think), and that one was hard too — I think because she quotes a ton of beautiful passages and then tries to analyze them, which I just can’t follow on audiobook. I just got The Graveyard Book from the library, and so far I like it a lot!

  6. Amanda
    Amanda February 17, 2009 at 11:57 am | | Reply

    I’m not so big of a fan of audiobooks, and tend only to listen to them if the book I want to read isn’t available in my library system or if the book I’m reading isn’t holding my attention and i have to finish it (for a book club or something). I’ve tried listening in the car or on the treadmill, and it doesn’t work out well for me. I think that’s probably because I listen to complicated books like classics, and generally get them from librivox, which as you point out is amateur narration. I’ve never listened to a professional audiobook, so maybe I’d feel differently about them, but as I’m rarely in the car and tend to enjoy watching movies while I’m on the treadmill, I probably won’t start, either.

    It doesn’t help that I can read a book much faster than I can listen to an audiobook. I get impatient and just want to be done.

  7. Heather J.
    Heather J. February 17, 2009 at 12:11 pm | | Reply

    I’m a HUGE audiobook fan, but I’m particular about my narrators. I’ve tried Libraryvox but I really don’t like them – I need a GOOD narrator, and a good story, in order to enjoy an audio book. The car is my favorite place to listen, but I also put them on when I’m making dinner, or cleaning the house, or taking a shower, or brushing my teeth, and sometimes even before bed.

    I think that there are some stories that are meant to be TOLD, or at least, that work well when they are told. THE THIRTEENTH TALE is one that comes to mind – a large part of the story is a woman telling her life story to another woman, so it really lent itself well to being an audio book.

    But there are others that don’t work out as well, that’s for sure (Bernard Cornwell’s STONEHENGE comes to mind).

    I’m glad you gave it a try, even it only works for you in specific situations – there’s lot to be said for getting to “read” a book while you’re in the process of packing/unpacking!

  8. Rebecca Reid
    Rebecca Reid February 17, 2009 at 1:15 pm | | Reply

    Steph, I think I’m a visual person too. That’s why it always surprises me to find that I’m loving listening to an audiobook. I do think it helps to already be familiar with a book when listening in audio — it’s not as confusing if you miss something for a moment.

    Kim, I think I’m going to turn to YA for audiobooks too. That’s a great idea!

    Amanda, listening to “professional” audiobooks is a completely different experience from Librivox. I can handle librivox — or even computer-generate audiobooks — but a professional narration is so much better! The Shakespeare biography I’m listening too is narrated by a Shakespeare actor — he is doing a great job and it’s like I’m listening to a play (kind of). I also can’t listen to books while exercising. Just doesn’t work for me. I get impatient too. But I get even more impatient with my chores/packing etc. when I’m not doing anything with my mind…

    Heather J., yes it was refreshing to enjoy *something* about packing!

  9. Lenore
    Lenore February 17, 2009 at 1:45 pm | | Reply

    I’ve tried to listen to two audiobooks:

    Hamlet – in the car (nearly crashed when I nearly fell asleep)

    All the Pretty Horses – in the bathtub (nearly drowned when I nearly fell asleep)

    Both attempts were aborted in favor of the actual book in hand.

    That said, I have 4 audio books now that I might try listening to next time my husband is driving the car on a longish trip.

  10. Ladytink_534
    Ladytink_534 February 17, 2009 at 4:04 pm | | Reply

    I think Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson was the last audiobook I let read to me. Unless you count the online videos of Neil Gaiman reading The Graveyard Book which I listened to.

  11. Chain Reader
    Chain Reader February 20, 2009 at 1:05 pm | | Reply

    In a non-hectic world, I would always choose to read a book over listening. But having four kids generates an amazing amount of laundry and housework (even though they help), and I would just go nuts if I didn’t have audiobooks to listen to while wasting my time cleaning up things that get messed up or dirty soon after! I had to really learn to listen well, it took my first few to get the hang of it. I have learned that I do not listen well in the car for some reason, so I do that less. When I signed up for goodreads which allows you to put books into categories, I realized that I’ve listened to about 50 books over the last couple of years. I’m still picky though–I won’t listen to something that I know is going to be really, really good because want the full experience of having the book in my hands and turning the pages.
    I could really go on and on about this topic! Three books that I rated five stars on good reads are Fast Food Nation, Mrs. Piggle Wiggle, and A Crooked Kind of Perfect. Non-fiction and children’s books seem to be my favorite form of audio.
    Anyway, congrats on your new house!

  12. Rebecca Reid
    Rebecca Reid February 20, 2009 at 4:02 pm | | Reply

    Lenore, Ha Ha! Yeah, maybe don’t be in front of the wheel next time. I hope it works out for you.

    Ladytink, I think that counts. I imagine hearing the author read his own work would be super cool!!

    Chain Reader, I *loved* listening to my mother read me Mrs PiggleWiggle. That’s a great idea for an audiobook! I also prefer nonfiction to fiction, probably because of what you say: I want the pleasure of reading it myself, and I always look forward to fiction like that!

  13. Jackie (Farm Lane Books)
    Jackie (Farm Lane Books) February 24, 2009 at 1:16 pm | | Reply

    I’ve only just started listening to audio books, so now I can listen to a few extra books in the car. I much prefer reading actual books though, and try to limit audio books to lighter reads.

    I’m your partner for the Dewey mini challenge! Which sort of books are out of your comfort zone? I’d quite like to read the same thing as you, and compare notes. I’ve never read a graphic novel or a western, but am up for other suggestions.

  14. Rebecca Reid
    Rebecca Reid February 25, 2009 at 12:44 pm | | Reply

    Jackie, I much prefer to read a book too! Looking forward to the mini challenge!

I would love to hear your thoughts; please feel free to share them with me! However, please note that as the blog owner, I have the right to remove any comment that is off topic, defamatory, obscene, or abusive, or that uses language that is not family friendly. If you would like further clarification, please read the comments policy.

Leave a Reply

Advertisement