Thoughts about reading fiction, nonfiction, and children’s books, new and old
Booking Through Thursday: What, in your opinion, is the definition of a “reader.” A person who indiscriminately reads everything in sight? A person who reads BOOKS? A person who reads, period, no matter what it is? … Or, more specific? Like the specific person who’s reading something you wrote?
I think a reader is one who *likes* reading and reads because they like it. So, my seven-year-old nephew, who is always reading something, is a reader. On the other hand, someone who reads a novel for tenth grade English class is not necessarily a reader. They may be going through the motions, but they might not really don’t care for the written word. (That said, just because a person is reading a book for an assignment doesn’t mean they are not a reader in that moment.)
For an analogy, I turn to the world of sewing. A person who sews a dress for herself or her daughter is a seamstress (not me, as I’d never do that). A person who rehems a pair of pants is just hemming a pair of pants (that might be me). I can sew but I’m not passionate about it, and I wouldn’t consider myself a “seamstress”. I think the definition of “reader” is similar.
After reading HTR&W’s prologue the other day, I asked a similar question: How does one read well? It doesn’t take much to be a reader and enjoy reading. But what makes that reading good reading?
I wrote a very long post discussing and analyzing Harold Bloom’s argument to the question “why read?” Don’t feel you have to read all of that post, but I’d love to hear you weigh in there (or here if you prefer).
Related Posts on Rebecca Reads:<< Previous Post HTR&W Prologue: Why Read?
A Few Fairy Tale Reviews Next Post >>
This blog is a collection of my thoughts about books and reading and reviews of books I've read. I'd love to hear your thoughts, too. Please share!
From October 2008-July 2009, I'm hosting the Really Old Classics Challenge.
Also, as an ongoing personal challenge, I'm reading all the works on the How to Read and Why reading list compiled by Harold Bloom. I'd love for you to either join me in this challenge or to follow along with me as I try to learn to read well.
Sally
Friday, June 27, 2008 at 9:09 am
The key, I think, is to be “passionate about it.”
Chris
Friday, June 27, 2008 at 10:22 am
I agree!
Rebecca Reid
Saturday, June 28, 2008 at 7:01 am
@Sally: Yes, passion makes a hobby, I think!
Rose City Reader
Sunday, June 29, 2008 at 1:24 am
I’ve been passively mulling this same issue for a couple of weeks, ever since I had a conversation with a very close friend. She is one of the few people who actually reads everything I write on my blog (that’s enough to put her is a Reader Hall of Fame in my opinion), we are in a book group together, and she often asks me for book recommendations. So I thought she read a lot of books.
But when I asked her about her progress on a book I had given her, she hadn’t gotten past the first few pages. She confessed that she doesn’t really read more than a handful of books in a year. She was very quick to say, though, “I’m a big reader, but I just don’t read many books.” She reads a lot of magazines, many of then substantive, like The Smithsonian, from cover to cover, and she reads several blogs, newspapers, etc.
I confess that rocked me loose on my pins a little. Deep down, I only considered someone to be a reader if they read books. And were I totally honest, it they made an effort to read at least some “serious” books. But here is someone who equally considers herself to be “a reader” and justifiably so. It made me think.
Rebecca Reid
Sunday, June 29, 2008 at 6:25 am
@Rose City Reader: I like her claim–I think quality of reading is just as important as quantity. Some people are slow readers and only read so much, but they still make time for it, even if it’s less than I do, and they still enjoy it very much. I still think they are readers. Thanks for sharing that example!
Jessica
Tuesday, July 1, 2008 at 12:16 pm
I have HTR&W too. I’m very impressed with your personal goal to read all of the books he mentions. As for what makes reading “good,” I have thought about that myself. Sometimes I tend to read things too quickly. Since joining the lit blog world, I’ve tried to read more intently, making notes after a reading session, post-it noting particular pages. I think good reading comes down to intention.
Rebecca Reid
Tuesday, July 1, 2008 at 1:02 pm
@Jessica: We’ll see how the reading of the list goes! It’s going to take a while. I agree, I like how blogging about my books makes me think about them more. “Intention”, that’s an interesting concept. I’ve noticed there are some books that I don’t read well, and I’m not bothering to read them well. (Almost like I know they aren’t worth a very careful read.) So then, the question is, why am I reading that book? I only have so much time!
Stefanie
Saturday, July 19, 2008 at 11:36 pm
Susan at Pages Turned just tipped me off about your project. I just started reading How to Read and Why the other day. I have a love-hate relationship with Bloom, but I like your idea!
Rebecca Reid
Monday, July 21, 2008 at 1:57 pm
@Stefanie: I kind of agree with the Bloom thing. The more I read of HTR&W, the more I realize I don’t really need to. But I like his reading list and it’s a challenge for me. I’m enjoying how it gets me reading these works I may never have picked up before.