2012 Caldecott and Geisel Awards Announced!

Note: I occasionally accept review copies from the publisher. Posts written from review copies are labeled. All opinions are my own. Posts may contain affiliate links. I may receive compensation for any purchased items.

I suspect that most children’s lit readers of this blog have already discovered the announcements for the ALA Youth Media Awards, but nevertheless, I really wanted to give my thoughts, since this year I made a huge effort to read the recently published children’s picture books as a part of the Cybils 2011 nomination process.

The Caldecott winner and honors are listed here. The three honor books are ones I completely loved and wanted to see recognized. All three of them had been nominated for the Cybils, and two had ended up on the finalist list. I personally was hoping Grandpa Green would be recognized as a Caldecott winner for its art: it’s simply fantastic, I think, although a number of people have expressed doubt given its limited kid appeal. (Raisin enjoyed it very much as well, although I do admit he didn’t love it as much as I did.) At any rate, I was surprised by A Ball for Daisy as the winner. Although I like Chris Raschka’s style in other books, Daisy just did not impress me (and it was not nominated for the CYBILS picture books award either, interestingly enough). Raisin liked it enough: we read it a few times. But I personally found the art a bit off-putting: it just wasn’t my style. It looked too raw to be a favorite. Nonetheless, I’m pretty satisfied with the three honor books, so I’ll take the fact that Daisy isn’t illustrated in my style with a grain of salt and accept the list as a good one.

What did you think of the Caldecott winner and honor books?

I haven’t read any of the nominees for most of the other categories, including the Newbery (maybe in a few years when Raisin is reading that reading level of book, then I’ll be “in the know”). There were a few books I recognized in other categories and a number that I’m excited to read at some point. But the only other category that caught my eye in terms of what I wanted to post about was the Geisel Award (named after Dr. Seuss of course) and selects great early reader books. The winner and the honors are named here.

I have not read the winner, Tales for Very Picky Eaters, but I think my son will enjoy that, as he has become rather picky lately about what he eats. I have read both the Elephant and Piggie honor book (I Broke My Trunk!) and I Want My Hat Back. I agree on those being fantastic for early readers. Raisin was quite proud of his ability to read I Want My Hat Back way back in May when I first gave him the review copy I received from BEA. And again, I haven’t read the last honor book, See Me Run, which is about dogs. I’ll have to look it up.

I’m quite excited to explore the world of early readers in the coming months. Although I don’t intend to stop looking for fantastic picture books (I love them!) my son is starting to really enjoy the early readers we’ve found: he loves being able to read me a story. Elephant and Piggie were his first favorites, and this last week we discovered Fly Guy (yuck for me, but perfect for Raisin’s reading level and four-year-old sense of humor right now).

What early readers with similar reading level to Fly Guy can you suggest?

Reviewed on January 23, 2012

About the author 

Rebecca Reid

Rebecca Reid is a homeschooling, stay-at-home mother seeking to make the journey of life-long learning fun by reading lots of good books. Rebecca Reads provides reviews of children's literature she has enjoyed with her children; nonfiction that enhances understanding of educational philosophies, history and more; and classical literature that Rebecca enjoys reading.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}