Good Masters! Sweet Ladies! by Laura Amy Schlitz

Note: I occasionally accept review copies from the publisher. Posts written from review copies are labeled. All opinions are my own. Posts may contain affiliate links. I may receive compensation for any purchased items.

When I heard the concept of Good Masters! Sweet Ladies! by Laura Amy Schlitz (monologues given by  medieval children), I thought it would be horribly boring. Monologues? I thought. What is fun about monologues? I thought children would be bored by these “Voices from a Medieval Village.”

To my delight, I found Good Masters! Sweet Ladies! to be easy and fun to read. I loved meeting the youth of Schlitz’s created medieval village and I would love to see a group of children perform this collection of monologues: it is a collection of personalities, and it shows how every person in a village has a role, be they rich or poor. I think children would like this book as well!

Monologues of Medieval Life

The students where librarian Laura Amy Schlitz worked were studying the Middle Ages, and she wanted them to perform something – but plays rarely have 17 main parts, and everyone wanted a main part. So she took it upon herself to create a village setting and write monologues or dialogues for all the youths in the class. The end result was Good Masters! Sweet Ladies!, and it won the Newbery Award for excellence in Children’s Literature.

In Good Masters! Sweet Ladies!, we meet the daughter and nephew of the feudal lord, a plowboy, a doctor’s son, a religious pilgrim, the miller’s son, the village half-wit, the moneylender’s son and a merchant’s daughter, and many other peasants. My favorite was Alice, the shepherdess: her sheep was dying and she sang it back to life, a story based on a real one (in more modern times). My other favorite was Mogg, who, upon her father’s death, learns that the lord has the right to take the best of their livestock, a fact she’s quite angry about; to her and my delight, her story ends happily.

Every person of the village expresses their frustrations and challenges. As we learn of their individual worries and problems, we see how they don’t understand each other. Interspersed throughout the book are short, two-page informational sections clarifying things: Why did villagers dislike the miller? Why was the pilgrim traveling? Why weren’t Jews liked? From what was the runaway fleeing?

I finished the book knowing more about medieval society. I also better appreciated everyone’s role in society today.

Performance as Literature

Schlitz was quite right in her portrayals of Christian medieval youth as “acting” their literature. According to Chapter 3 (“Court, Commerce and Cloister”) of Seth Lerer’s Children’s Literature: A Reader’s History from Aesop to Harry Potter, just as religious services were performances, the literature of a medieval childhood was performed.

Children were given lots of responsibilities, from medieval courts of leadership to craft guilds, and each role had literature for the children. The literature of medieval childhood included the earliest lullabies, religious primers, and courtesy/conduct manuals. Much of the learning was through riddles, and these riddles were “dialogue[s] between master and students” (page 63).

Lerer illustrates how medieval literature wasn’t only performance: it was also “romance and adventure, Robin Hood and magic, lullabies and folk rhymes” (page 80).  While I certainly don’t wish to have lived as a child in medieval times, it’s refreshing to see, in history, literature beginning to develop for children.

It seems quite appropriate that Good Masters! Sweet Ladies! allows modern children to enter the medieval world in a similar way. I’d highly recommend this book for children and parents alike.

Reviewed on October 23, 2008

About the author 

Rebecca Reid

Rebecca Reid is a homeschooling, stay-at-home mother seeking to make the journey of life-long learning fun by reading lots of good books. Rebecca Reads provides reviews of children's literature she has enjoyed with her children; nonfiction that enhances understanding of educational philosophies, history and more; and classical literature that Rebecca enjoys reading.

  • Like you, I thought this would be boring, but I was very wrong! I just read it for the 24-hour-readathon and absolutely loved it.

  • We have this book at the library and I have been wanting to read it, however, I am far behind on my reading as it is.  I have been meaning to start something new with our small patrons, maybe I should get them started on this and let them do a performance for the public.

  • Chain Reader, it would be a good one for the read-a-thon I imagine!

    Natasha, I remember you said you didn’t like the cover and I can see that too! The premise doesn’t exactly seem all that friendly. Too bad because it was nice!

    Deidre, I’d love to see a performance of this! It would be so much fun! Minimal set, props needed. How great!

  • I love reading the reviews here to give me guidance on books I’ll enjoy.  

    Please also enter me for the Spooktacular Hachette Book Group Giveaway (Hatchette USA).

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}