I donโt normally read memoirs, but Iโm finding that I really love to read political or journalistic memoirs when they are in graphic novel form. They are a fast read, and I learn so much about a different countryโs political situation in a new perspective. I love that I can see the country via a comic. Of course, the danger of reading a political memoir is that it is obviously skewed toward one personโs perspective: I cannot see the entire picture.
In the case of Pyongyang: A Journey in North Korea, Guy Delisleโs perspective may be one of the few such memoirs of a visit to North Korea. Although I knew that North Korea was a communist nation, the facts that Delisle shares of his two months working there are quite astonishing. Itโs hard to believe that such a dystopian country exists contemporary to my own. For the less ignorant, Pyongyang wonโt be a shock. Regardless, the comic reads like a novel, and Iโm glad for the glimpse into a world I didnโt quite know existed as such.
I wondered a little bit, as I read, if Delisle had this book in mind when he began his trip. The novel he decides to bring with him is George Orwellโs 1984, and he seems to seek out edgy things to say and do. Yet, maybe it was hard not to. Pyongyang the city had no entertainment and as a new visitor, Iโm sure Iโd likewise be clueless. Before reading this, I didnโt realize that Orwellโs 1984 was a reality in a nation on the earth.
The similarities between 1984 and the North Korean world Delisle portrays are striking. Here are just a few things that seemed right out of Orwell:
- Pictures of Big Brother on the walls (i.e., Kim and Kim Jr.).
- โVolunteersโ cutting the grass with a sickle.
- Restaurants named with numbers.
- A classroom of cookie cutter children playing the accordion perfectly (as depicted on the cover).
- The lack of entertainment.
- The lack of contact with the rest of the world.
- The sense of country-worship Delisleโs guides obviously express.
- The lack of any disabled people.
- The fact that everyone informs on everyone else as โspies.โ
It was rather scary and certainly uncomfortable. This is today. This is not a dystopian novel!
Although the political situation was uncomfortable, the graphic novel as a whole was actually quite funny. Delisle was bored, so he found things to do. And he had some great discussions with his guide and his translator. I loved the scene where he asked his translator what he thought of the novel heโd lent him (1984). Oh my, did that man hurry to return the novel. โI donโt like science fiction!โ he exclaimed, sweating profusely. I do wonder, though, if North Korean authorities are going to find that man and make him pay for that simple appearance in this novel (similar to the aftermath of newspaper photos of Tiannaman Square). It worried me.
In the end, it was a great read. I learned about the world but I also was entertained. I enjoyed the artwork too. It helped me see this world that seems to foreign from my own.
You seemed to enjoy this book more than I did. I have a great deal of difficulty with graphic novels because I tend to focus too much on the text and ignore the pictures. But this was definitely a worthwhile read. And I too worried about what might happen to his guide …
.-= Heather J.ยดs last post on blog ..Audiobook Week: Persuasion, by Jane Austen =-.
Heather J., I thought that would be the case, but I’m a visual learner so I actually have found reading comics to be a nice compliment to my visual preference. If you want to learn about how comics work, read UNDERSTANDING COMICS. It is so awesome and gave me a great perspective of the medium for novels, memoirs, etc.
This looks interesting. You are right that type type of memoir (graphic or not) are often one-sided, but obviously it’s a side that the author feels needs to be shared. I’m also wondering how DeLisle managed to get in North Korea, and for that long of a time.
.-= Valerieยดs last post on blog ..Nicholas Sparks, and Junior High School Journalism =-.
Valerie, he’s Canadian. He was working with a French company, heading the cartooning department for two months. The book was originally written in French; I read it in translation.
Whenever I read non-fiction history I always feel like I’m just getting a small piece of the puzzle, and always want to read much more, but I’ve accepted that it’s just impossible unless I wanted to devote my study to one subject. So I just try to enjoy the little exposure I’m getting.
This sounds very intriguing! I’ve always wanted to learn more about North Korea–it’s such a mind-boggling country.
.-= Shelleyยดs last post on blog ..The Happy Homemaker’s Guide to Audiobooks =-.
Shelley, that’s why I like graphic novel memoirs — it’s not too much. Sometimes I get bored with full length very long accounts of nonfiction because even then it’s just a piece of the puzzle. I do hope you read this — it’s an experience!
Another good political comics memoirist is Joe Sacco. I’ve read his books Palestine and Safe Area Gorazde and they’re both amazing.
.-= Luยดs last post on blog ..Nerds Heart YA โ THE DECISION =-.
Lu, I LOVED PALESTINE by Joe Sacco. Haven’t read Safe Area Gorazde yet but it’s definitely on the list.
I like memoirs better in graphic novel form too! For some reason, a graphic novel makes real-life introspection and reflection go down better. Thanks for the suggestion.
.-= Trishaยดs last post on blog ..Sunday Salon: The Awards Pages =-.
Trisha, I hope you enjoy it! It’s a nice way to learn about North Korea, too.
I just received my order for this book! I went to South Korea 2 years ago and have heard about the state of North Korea a fair bit, so I can’t wait to read this graphic novel, which is probably the only book set in North Korea. (I never know any other books)
.-= meeยดs last post on blog ..To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee =-.
mee, yeah! I hope you enjoy it. Especially since you’ve been to South Korea! I think you’ll love it.
This looks interesting. I’ve not tried graphic novels, but this one might be worth a try.
.-= Suzanneยดs last post on blog ..It Could Be Worse, You Could Be Me — by Ariel Leve =-.
Suzanne, knowing your interest in all things relating to Holocaust stories, I think you’d love the graphic novel THE COMPLETE MAUS. It’s a really powerful one and a great introduction to graphic novels as a format.
I don’t think reading a book like this would ever have occurred to me had I not read your review. I read a couple graphic novels while studying for my M.A. (for a young adult literature course), and liked those, but for whatever reason I just haven’t gotten back to them again. Guess I’ve just been too busy with more traditional prose. Now I wonder what’s out there that I’m missing.
.-= Lisa Guidariniยดs last post on blog ..Tally ho, all! =-.
Lisa, I was quite suspicious of graphic novels/comics but I have found that there are comics in every genre. I liked THE COMPLETE MAUS (did you read that for your YA lit course?) and for nonfiction UNDERSTANDING COMICS is a great look at the format as a whole. I hope you find some you enjoy!
Oh cool, I’m glad this is good. I just recently read his next book (I think next) about living in Burma, and also found it educational and interesting. I like the way he was able to find humor in everyday situations even in a terrible place. I’ll be looking for this one too.
.-= Kim (Sophisticated Dorkiness)ยดs last post on blog ..Guest Post on The 3 Rโs Blog: Fact in Fiction =-.
Kim, I think I saw your review of the Burma one and it reminded me of this one my list! I know nothing about Burma so I should check that one out too! I hope you enjoy this look at N Korea
This review has sold me on buying this book. North Korea really is a study in a real live dystopia… Thanks!
Darryl
Dystopian Journal
dysjo.com
Darryl, I think you’d enjoy this, given your interest in dystopias. That style of life he describes is eerily similar to 1984….
I am always on the look out for new graphic novels to add to my TBR list and this one sounds perfect! I don’t know much about North Korea so it will be entertaining and educational.
.-= Stefanieยดs last post on blog ..My Last Summer Quarter at Library School =-.
Stefanie, I hope you enjoy it!
I kept worrying about Delisle – you’re right, he did seem to be going out of his way to be a troublemaker. I was afraid he was going to get himself in trouble with the scary police people, or worse, get his guides into trouble. But I still thought it was a wonderful book. ๐
.-= Jennyยดs last post on blog ..Review: Day of Tears, Julius Lester =-.
Jenny, I did worry about his poor guides! But yes, a fun book! Glad you enjoyed it too.
What an excellent blog about books…I will add a link to you on my blog list…I’ll be back again soon to browse…
.-= Laura J. W. Ryanยดs last post on blog ..Opening night at The Gallery =-.
Thanks, Laura!
This sounds very interesting. I’ve never read a graphic novel for “adults” (that is, not manga), but the dystopian genre is one of my favorites, so I’ll definitely pick this up. I know pretty much nothing about North Korea so I’m sure I’ll learn something. I just checked and my library has a copy. Thanks for the review.
.-= teachergirlยดs last post on blog ..The Education of Bet =-.
teachergirl, I’ve never read a manga but I have found that I enjoy graphic novels. Are manga ever nonfiction? I tend to enjoy graphic novels a lot in nonfiction.
I love this book. It’s so melancolical. It’s the plight of the expat in some countries ๐